Private credit hits 26% of U.S. insurer assets, Demotech says

Image
Private credit hits 26% of U.S. insurer assets, Demotech says

UNITED STATES -- November 19, 2026 -- Private credit made up 26% of U.S. insurers' cash and invested assets in 2025, up from 18% in 2016, according to an analysis from Demotech, Inc., which issues Financial Stability Ratings. The increase of 8 percentage points came mainly from life insurers, whose private placement bond holdings grew from $878 billion to $1,972 billion. That is a rise of about $1,094 billion, or roughly 2.2 times the starting level, by our calculation.

The figures come from Schedule D of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) annual statement, sourced via S&P Global. They cover only U.S.-domiciled companies filing with the NAIC. Demotech excluded mortgages from direct lending (Schedule B) and equity-classified funds that track private credit. Mieley Cooke, who provides financial and business analysis for Demotech, says private credit data is difficult to compile and that definitions vary between parties.

Life insurers drive growth while the below-investment-grade share stays low

Demotech says the share of private credit allocated to below investment grade has remained low and stable. P&C and health insurers have also grown their holdings, from a much lower dollar base. Most of their private placements are SEC Rule 144A bonds, which can trade without public registration. Life insurers hold more non-144A bonds. Demotech attributes the split to differing liquidity needs: longer-tailed life and annuity products can absorb more illiquidity.

Demotech says private placements typically trade 50-150 basis points above a comparably rated corporate bond, reflecting liquidity risk and accounting nuance. Alternative investments, not all of them private credit, have grown for life and health insurers and shrunk for P&C insurers.

NAIC's bond definition has reclassified some instruments since January 2025

A principles-based NAIC rule, effective Jan. 1, 2025, requires a true creditor relationship and an instrument that functions as an issuer credit obligation or an asset-backed security. Instruments that fail the test are classified as alternative investments and receive less favorable risk-based capital treatment. Demotech says some life companies had used exotic structures to gain bond treatment for equity-like instruments.

Regulators focus on private equity-backed life insurers and offshore reinsurance

Demotech says regulator concern has grown that asset risks are being obscured or ignored. It points to life companies backed by large private equity asset managers, which use complex reinsurance structures to raise private credit exposure quickly and with limited public transparency. It names Apollo's Athene and KKR's Global Atlantic as examples. According to Demotech, the strategy has supported growth in fixed annuities by lifting yields and policyholder crediting rates. The asset managers may also earn investment management fees from affiliated insurers.

Regulators are particularly concerned about life blocks, typically fixed annuities, ceded to offshore entities that then invest in private credit. Those holdings sit outside the data above, and Demotech does not quantify them.

Larger insurers are better placed to run private credit books, Demotech says

Private credit requires qualified professionals, time and resources for asset-liability management, accounting and liquidity oversight. Demotech says larger companies can justify that cost more easily than smaller ones, and may have liability profiles that better support the asset class.

Demotech rates predominantly P&C and title insurers, where it says private credit is generally less of a concern for its ratings. It also rates a small selection of life insurers, which tend to be smaller and well capitalized. Qualified analysts monitor their private credit closely. Cooke joined Demotech in 2024 after working as a life insurance actuary for a major carrier.

Published by:
fairsonline_team
Target market(s)
News Type